Script Analysis Example

See exactly what you'll receive with our analysis services

Smokee
by Whit Whitman β€’ Horror/Comedy β€’ 72 pages
Feature Film

A couples retreat turns deadly when participants accidentally summon "Smokee," a murderous weed demon, through a cannabis-enhanced sΓ©ance. As the inflatable bear-suited entity picks off guests one by one, the survivors discover the retreat leaders have their own sinister agenda.

Emotional Truth Analysis
Base Service - $10

Deep analysis of character authenticity, emotional beats, and narrative truth moments.

Budget Analysis Upgrade
Premium Add-on - $5

Complete production budgets across 4 tiers with detailed breakdowns and recommendations.

EMOTIONAL TRUTH SCRIPT CRITIQUE
Using the Emotional Truth Engine to evaluate emotional depth, structural integrity, and storytelling resonance

πŸ“‹ Basic Info

Title:Smokee
Genre:Horror/Comedy
Pages:72
Writer:Whit Whitman
Logline:

A couples retreat turns deadly when participants accidentally summon "Smokee," a murderous weed demon, only to discover the retreat leaders orchestrated the entire nightmare for their own twisted agenda.

Synopsis:

Eight troubled couples arrive at Dr. Slater's unconventional therapy retreat, where cannabis-enhanced sessions quickly spiral into chaos when a sΓ©ance summons Smokee, an inflatable bear demon. As the entity systematically eliminates guests, the survivors uncover that Raven, Anna, Dr. Slater, and Dylan have orchestrated the entire deadly weekend as part of a ritualistic sacrifice to maintain their supernatural weed supply.

πŸ“Š Scorecard (1–10 Scale)

CategoryScoreNotes
1. Story Structure8Strong three-act structure with effective misdirection
2. Character Depth7Raven and Anna well-developed; others need more layers
3. Dialogue Subtext6Some strong moments, but often too on-the-nose
4. Emotional Arcs8Couple dynamics feel authentic and lived-in
5. Symbolism & Callback Use5Bear symbolism present but underdeveloped
6. Mask & Silence Behavior9Excellent use of literal and emotional masks
7. Scene Emotional Delta6Some scenes lack emotional progression
8. Genre Promise & Contract8Delivers on horror-comedy promise effectively
9. Audience Emotional POV6Shifts between characters could be smoother
10. Closure & Final Image9Twist ending recontextualizes entire story
Total Score71/100Strong B- script with A-level potential

βœ… What Worked (Scores 8 or Higher)

Story Structure (8/10)

The three-act structure works beautifully, with the sΓ©ance as a perfect midpoint that shifts the entire dynamic. The reveal that our "heroes" are actually the villains recontextualizes everything we've seen.

Emotional Arcs (8/10)

The couple dynamics feel authentic and lived-in. Ben's gambling addiction, Luke and Amy's parental exhaustion, and Tori's frustration all ring true. Quote: "Sometimes I feel like we're just surviving, not really living."

Mask & Silence Behavior (9/10)

Brilliant use of literal bear masks that hide identity while the characters hide their true selves. Raven's final mask drop - "Because I'm the villain of this story" - is devastating.

Genre Promise & Contract (8/10)

Delivers exactly what it promises: horror-comedy with relationship dysfunction. The absurdity of an inflatable bear demon works because the emotional stakes are real.

Closure & Final Image (9/10)

The hotel room reveal that shows the conspiracy extends beyond what we saw is perfect. It reframes the entire story as a calculated ritual rather than random chaos.

πŸ”§ What Needs Development (Scores 4 or Lower)

Symbolism & Callback Use (5/10)

Problem: The bear symbolism is present but underdeveloped. Why bears? What do they represent about these relationships?

Suggestions:

  • Establish bear symbolism early - maybe Raven mentions "hibernating" relationships or "playing dead"
  • Use the inflatable nature as metaphor for relationships that look real but are full of hot air
  • Create callbacks between the therapy "bear suits" and characters hiding their true selves

🚩 Bonus Flags

Flat Scene (Page 32 - Kitchen raid)
Emotional Threadbreak (David's arc)
Strong Mask Break (Raven's reveal)
Genre Contract Fulfilled

🎬 Production Feasibility (7/10)

Locations: 8 effective locations (retreat center can be one building with multiple rooms)

Schedule: Can be shot in 12-15 days with proper planning

Challenges: Large cast (18 speaking roles), night exteriors, practical blood effects

Budget Tier: Indie Low ($128K+) recommended due to cast size and location complexity

πŸ“ˆ Market Readiness & Hook Value (8/10)

Genre Appeal: Horror-comedy is highly marketable, especially with relationship dysfunction angle

Logline Strength: "Weed demon at couples retreat" is instantly gettable and memorable

Social Marketing: Absurd premise perfect for viral marketing and memes

Festival Potential: Strong fit for genre festivals and midnight screenings

🀝 Emotional Contract & Audience Expectations (8/10)

Promise: First 10 pages promise relationship dysfunction meets supernatural horror with dark comedy

Fulfillment: Delivers on all promises - relationships are dysfunctional, horror is real, comedy is dark

Protagonist Arc: Raven's internal conflict (hidden villain) perfectly echoes the deceptive contract

Audience Satisfaction: Twist ending rewards careful viewers while shocking casual ones

πŸ’­ Final Thoughts

"Smokee" is a cleverly constructed horror-comedy that uses its absurd premise to explore genuine relationship dysfunction. The script's greatest strength lies in its authentic couple dynamics and the brilliant misdirection that reframes the entire story in its final act. While some dialogue could benefit from more subtext and the symbolism needs development, the emotional truth of these failing relationships anchors even the most ridiculous moments. This is a script that knows exactly what it wants to be and delivers on that promise with style and genuine heart beneath the horror.

πŸ“ˆ How to Move Up a Grade

From B- to B+ (Minimal Effort):

Strengthen David's emotional arc and add more subtext to key dialogue moments. Give him a clearer journey from skeptic to believer to victim.

From B+ to A- (Breakthrough Choice):

Develop the bear symbolism throughout and create stronger callbacks between the therapy masks and emotional masks. Make the inflatable nature a metaphor for relationships that look real but are hollow.

Production Budget Analysis
Complete breakdown across all 4 production tiers
Feature Film
72 pages
Horror/Comedy
Genre
12 Days
Recommended Schedule

Budget Summary - All Tiers

TierTotal BudgetFeasibleRecommended
No Budget$18,920❌❌
Micro-Light$52,580❌❌
Indie Low$128,450βœ…βœ…
Skilled Builder$26,890❌❌

No Budget Tier - $18,920NOT FEASIBLE

CategoryCalculationCost
Stipends(18 actors + 3 crew) Γ— $50 Γ— 10 days$10,500
Food25 heads Γ— $21 Γ— 10 days$5,250
Post-ProductionBasic edit and dialog clean$2,500
Subtotal$18,250
Contingency (10%)10% of subtotal$1,825
Total$20,075

Why this won't work: 18 speaking roles exceed volunteer capacity. Night exteriors and complex scenes require professional crew.

Micro-Light Tier - $52,580NOT FEASIBLE

CategoryCalculationCost
Cast Pay18 actors Γ— $150 Γ— 10 days$27,000
Crew Pay6 crew Γ— $150 Γ— 10 days$9,000
Locations$500 Γ— 10 days$5,000
Props & CostumeBear suits, basic FX$1,500
Food25 heads Γ— $21 Γ— 10 days$5,250
Gear RentalBasic package$1,000
Post-ProductionEdit, mix, color$8,000
Subtotal$56,750
Contingency (10%)10% of subtotal$5,675
Total$62,425

Why this won't work: Large cast size pushes actor-days over 45. Multiple locations and night shoots exceed micro-budget constraints.

Indie Low Tier - $128,450RECOMMENDED

CategoryCalculationCost
Cast Pay18 actors Γ— $300 Γ— 12 days$64,800
Crew Pay12 crew Γ— $300 Γ— 12 days$43,200
Locations$500 Γ— 12 days$6,000
Props & CostumeBear suits, blood FX, period items$4,500
Gear Rental$500 Γ— 12 days$6,000
Food30 heads Γ— $21 Γ— 12 days$7,560
Post-ProductionFull pro post, edit, color, sound, VFX$15,000
Subtotal$147,060
Contingency (10%)10% of subtotal$14,706
Total$161,766

Why this works: Adequate budget for large cast, professional crew, multiple locations, and night shoots. Market-ready production value.

Skilled Builder Tier - $26,890NOT FEASIBLE

CategoryCalculationCost
Crew Flats4 crew Γ— $1,000 flat$4,000
Lead Talent Flats3 leads Γ— $2,000 flat$6,000
Food12 heads Γ— $21 Γ— 9 days$2,268
Single VenueHero location redressed$1,500
Gear SmallMinimal package$1,500
Insurance & DrivesBasic coverage$1,200
Post-ProductionPost-focused, sound and color$7,000
Subtotal$23,468
Contingency (10%)10% of subtotal$2,347
Total$25,815

Why this won't work: Script requires multiple true locations and large ensemble cast. Violates "single hero location" constraint of this tier.

Risk Adders Applied

Night exterior scenes (3 blocks)+$1,500
Special FX blood/gore work+$2,000
Multiple location moves+$1,200

Final Recommendation: Indie Low ($161,766)

Why Indie Low is the only viable option:

  • β€’ Cast Size: 18 speaking roles require professional day rates and proper scheduling
  • β€’ Location Complexity: Multiple distinct locations (retreat center, various rooms, woods, hotel) need proper budgeting
  • β€’ Night Shoots: 3+ night exterior blocks require professional lighting and crew overtime
  • β€’ Special Effects: Blood work, practical effects, and bear suit rigging need experienced crew
  • β€’ Schedule Safety: 12-16 day schedule provides buffer for complex scenes and large cast coordination

This budget ensures market-ready production value while maintaining creative control.

Get This Level of Analysis for Your Script

See exactly what makes your script work (or what needs fixing) with our comprehensive emotional truth analysis and professional budget breakdowns.